Tag Archives: Grundgesetz

On that circumcision decision

Posted on 2012-06-27 by Gilbert

You probably heard the news of a German court declaring circumcision illegal. As a German religion blogger blogging in English I probably should comment on that. So first I’ll explain what happened and then I’ll offer some commentary. The abstract … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , , | 14 Comments

Constitution blogging day wrapup

Posted on 2012-03-18 by Gilbert

This ends my day of blogging on the German constitution. Technically, the day ended two hours ago, but I didn’t finish in time.  I didn’t cover everything worth covering. For example, a lot could be said about proportional representation, international … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , | Comments Off on Constitution blogging day wrapup

Delegation and Europe

Posted on 2012-03-18 by Gilbert

Germany is traditionally big on European integration. And indeed European integration has gone much further than anyone would have expected, say, 30 years ago. In fact it has gone much further than most Europeans realize. Right now I won’t explain … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Delegation and Europe

No direct democracy

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

One standard criticism of the Basic Law is that it doesn’t allow the people to ever vote on federal laws directly. This is a point I fully agree with. As I said in my last post, a simple majority at … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | Comments Off on No direct democracy

Eternal articles and judical review

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

One of the most famous features of the Basic Law is its eternity clause in article 79 (official translation, emphasis mine): Article 79 (1) This Basic Law may be amended only by a law expressly amending or supplementing its text. … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Half-hearted federalism

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

As the name might imply, the Federal Republic of Germany has constituent states. Federalism, of course, has many advantages. It keeps decisions closer to the people, allows laboratories for experimentation, etc. In theory most Germans agree with this, but when … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Half-hearted federalism

“Capital punishment is abolished.”

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

Those are the simple words of article 102 of the Basic Law. Nowadays most developed countries have abolished capital punishment and many have done so constitutionally. But in 1949 constitutional abolition was still unusual. We Germans tend to over-idealize this … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | Comments Off on “Capital punishment is abolished.”

How to choose a head of state

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

In my last post I approved of the German constitution’s design choice to have an apolitical head of state. Once that design choice is made the question is how to choose that head of state. The obvious first idea is … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | Comments Off on How to choose a head of state

The two-headed Leviathan

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

In my last post I argued against the parliamentary system. If I got my will, the absence of a stable majority in parliament would no longer mean a constitutional crisis. That would make the president’s reserve powers dispensable. But there … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , | Comments Off on The two-headed Leviathan

Nominal and actual power in the parlimentary system

Posted on 2012-03-17 by Gilbert

When the United States or even France elect a president it is big news.  The election of the German president not so much. That is, of course, because, at least in normal times, the German president doesn’t hold significant power. … Continue reading →

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Nominal and actual power in the parlimentary system